Drafted in the 3rd round (101st overall) by the Minnesota Twins in 2009 (signed for $324,900).
View Draft Report
Tootle fits in with other small-college high draft picks such as Kyle Heckathorn, Rex Brothers and Chad Jenkins who gained more experience by going to smaller schools and earning rotation time as freshmen. Tootle threw 174 innings his first two seasons at Jacksonville State and shined last summer in the Cape Cod League, where he ranked as the league's No. 4 prospect. He showed a 94-98 mph fastball last summer and similar velocity at times this spring. He's a hard worker and long-toss fan with a quick arm who holds his above-average velocity deep into games when he's physically right. Tootle missed about a month with a stomach virus that caused him to lose more than 10 pounds. In his first two outings after his time off, his velocity was down, but he was brilliant for four innings against Tennessee Tech, sitting 92-96 mph before he tired in the fifth inning.Tootle's secondary stuff remains in question as does the life on his fastball. He throws a hard slider that grades out as average and a changeup as well, though it's below-average. Most scouts consider Tootle a better bet to relieve despite his ability to throw hard for seven innings, as he showed when the last pitch of his seven-inning complete game against Austin Peay was 98 mph. His draft status might hinge on how he finishes and how well teams saw him last summer. He won't go in the first round as he might have right after last summer's performance, but he shouldn't be far behind his small-school brethren.
Top Rankings
Organization Prospect Rankings
Tootle is trying to top Todd Jones as the best Jacksonville State alumnus in major league history. He was the Ohio Valley Conference pitcher of the year in 2008 and then ranked as the No. 4 prospect in the Cape Cod League that summer, showing a fastball that reached 98 mph regularly. However, he missed a month last spring with a stomach virus that caused him to lose at least 10 pounds. He was never at his best, allowing Minnesota to grab him in the fourth round and sign him for $324,900. Tootle is a hard worker and long-toss fan with a quick arm who holds his above-average velocity deep into games when he's physically right. It took him a couple of starts last spring to get his velocity back, and he still couldn't maintain more than 92-96 mph velocity past the fifth inning. Pitching in relief and using his fastball almost exclusively, Tootle racked up groundouts in his brief pro debut. His fastball is far ahead of his secondary pitches, so he may be destined for the bullpen anyway. His slider is average at best, and he slows his arm noticeably when he throws his below-average changeup. The Twins plan to have him start in 2010 to further develop his secondary stuff, but even Tootle told club officials that he sees himself as a reliever in the long term.
Download our app
Read the newest magazine issue right on your phone