Drafted in the 7th round (234th overall) by the Washington Nationals in 2012 (signed for $145,000).
View Draft Report
The 1,000th overall pick in 2009 out of high school, Benincasa turned down the Blue Jays to attend Florida State, unlocking some of his potential as a junior relief ace. He made seven starts the previous two seasons and has a solid 6-foot-2, 195-pound frame and clean arm action that could return him to a starting role as a pro. He has mixed in a solid-average split-changeup but generally pitches off his 90-92 mph fastball, which regularly hits 93-94 and has good sink, and his slider, an above-average pitch with late action and decent depth.
Top Rankings
Organization Prospect Rankings
A first-team All-America closer during his 2012 junior year at Florida State, Benincasa saved 27 games between low Class A and high A in 2013, but his stuff fell off down the stretch as he wore down physically, partially a result of poor nutritional habits. At his best, Benincasa works in the 92-94 mph range and touches 96 with slightly above-average sink, but he sat around 89-92 late in the season. At full strength, his low-80s slider has good depth and rates as a 55 pitch on the 20-80 scale, but it was not as sharp late in the year. Benincasa has a solid third pitch in his split-changeup, giving him another weapon against lefties. He is a good athlete with plenty of poise in tight spots and promising feel for pitching, giving him a chance to reach the big leagues as a middle reliever. He'll need to do a better job putting on weight--and keeping it on--for him to reach that ceiling. Benincasa figures to advance to Double-A Harrisburg in 2014 and might not be far from the majors.
Draft Prospects
The 1,000th overall pick in 2009 out of high school, Benincasa turned down the Blue Jays to attend Florida State, unlocking some of his potential as a junior relief ace. He made seven starts the previous two seasons and has a solid 6-foot-2, 195-pound frame and clean arm action that could return him to a starting role as a pro. He has mixed in a solid-average split-changeup but generally pitches off his 90-92 mph fastball, which regularly hits 93-94 and has good sink, and his slider, an above-average pitch with late action and decent depth.
Download our app
Read the newest magazine issue right on your phone