Drafted in the 2nd round (62nd overall) by the Texas Rangers in 2009 (signed for $587,700).
View Draft Report
Mendonca is well known to college baseball fans for his tremendous performance--offensively and defensively--in last year's College World Series. He was the Most Outstanding Player in Fresno's unlikely run to the title in Omaha, and he has been nearly as good this season. Mendonca can be streaky both offensively and defensively. At 6-foot-1 and 210 pounds, he has unique power from the left side and puts on one of the best batting practice exhibitions in college baseball. He's a flyball hitter who looks to lift everything, and his opposite-field power is outstanding. On the 20-to-80 scouting scale, he already possesses 50 power, and projects to 60 raw power easily. He has a distinctive swing. He starts with his hands high, then drops them into an angled launch position. He can drive a ball out even if he doesn't get all of it. In an early-season game at Loyola Marymount, he was slightly fooled by a changeup, got out front and under the ball but still lofted it out of the park. Scouts worry about the fundamentals of his swing, however. He comes close to locking or blocking his hands out front in an arm bar action, and he shows a weakness with offspeed stuff, setting a Division I record with 99 strikeouts last season. There are similar questions about his defense, where he looks fluid going to his left but not to his right, and his arm varies from cannon to squirt gun. He doesn't run well. Still, the lure of Mendonca's power bat and record of rising to the occasion will entice an organization to select him as early as the second round.
Top Rankings
Organization Prospect Rankings
Mendonca's dazzling glovework and record-tying four home runs earned him Most Outstanding Player honors at the 2008 College World Series as a sophomore, as he led longshot Fresno State to the national title. He finished that year with 19 home runs, though he also set a Division I record with 99 strikeouts, illustrating his feast-or-famine approach. Mendonca slugged 27 home runs as a junior in 2009 and cut his strikeouts to 64, albeit in 15 fewer games. He signed for a $587,700 bonus after Texas drafted him in the second round, giving him time to make adjustments in his pro debut at Spokane. Scouts questioned Mendonca's bat in college because he would over-rotate his upper half, bury his hands and bar his front arm, giving him a long path to the ball and making him vulnerable to pitches above the knees. He was hitting just .200 after 15 games at Spokane before he started working with Rangers coaches to revamp his hitting mechanics. He made progress with shortening his swing and improving his timing, and he finished with an .898 OPS at Spokane. Mendonca's power projects as above average, so he could be a solid offensive player even if he's a below-average hitter. He's an aggressive hitter who must become more patient. Defensively, he has excellent hands and instincts at third base, and he excels at coming in on slow rollers. He'll be a plus defender with a plus arm if he can improve his lateral range and agility by getting in better shape. He's a below-average runner. Mendonca is a down-and-dirty baseball rat who works hard at his craft. The Rangers envision him as a solid everyday third baseman in the Graig Nettles mold. He'll likely open 2010 in low Class A but figures to finish the season in Bakersfield, where he spent 11 games at the end of his pro debut.
Minor League Top Prospects
Mendonca followed up winning College World Series MVP honors as a sophomore by ranking third in NCAA Division I with 27 homers as a junior, propelling him into the second round of the draft. He continued to hit for power in his pro debut, slugging .537 for Spokane before a promotion to high Class A. While the ball jumps off Mendonca's bat, he does have issues making contact (66 strikeouts in 188 at-bats) and more experienced pitchers could exploit his overly aggressive approach (he drew just nine walks). His bat path is a little too deep and he drops his hands during his swing, causing him to get underneath a lot of fastballs. Mendonca isn't quite on par with Martinez defensively, but he's close. He has good instincts, a quick transfer and short throwing motion. His throws can get sloppy, as he sometimes drops down and flips the ball across the diamond.
Best Tools List
Rated Best Defensive 3B in the Texas League in 2011
Download our app
Read the newest magazine issue right on your phone